Eric's Blog
Eric's Blog

Torbreck Wine Tasting

04.26.10  Torbreck Wines

I had the immense pleasure of spending Monday afternoon with my wife Linda at the Allison Inn & Spa tasting through quite a collection of the Torbreck wines. We were hosted by Rob Moller of Merchant of Vino and we were joined by Andrew Tierney, Director of Sales & Marketing for Torbreck and about sixteen other members of the trade from the Portland area. It was a typical cool, wet spring day and the room was air conditioned to help show the wines at the optimal temperature, but the wines were warming and helped to reaffirm that Australia does make some incredible wines of distinction. 

First off, the setting - The Allsion Inn & Spa located in Newberg is the first luxury destination in Willamette Valley's wine country. Not even a year old The Allsion has garnered lots of attention and critical acclaim for the high level of service, beautiful surroundings and attention to detail. We arrived early so that we could have lunch in Jory, their signature restaurant that features inventive dishes made from local ingredients. Not having a reservation might be a problem on a warm summer afternoon, but on a cool spring day we were seated almost immediately at a table that gave us a great view of the valley to the south. Since this is meant to be about the wines I won't waste too much space about The Allsion, but suffice it to say that the service was impeccable and the food was delicious. I would highly recommend it to my friends. In fact we are going to go back as a group for one of their Sunday Family Suppers that features three courses for $29.

Our first flight of wines provided the insight that Torbreck isn't just about big, burly reds. The 2008 Woodcutter's Semillon exhibits a bright yellow-gold color and projects orchard fruits and citrus zest to your nose and on the palate adds some herbs on the back end. This will compliment almost any seafood and went beautifully with the prosciutto-wrapped grilled prawns provided - 89/100. Our second white - 2010 The Bothie, is a fragrant Muscat Blanc a Petite Grains that is made as a "vin doux naturel" style by the addition of grape spirit to the fermenting must to halt the fermentation leaving some significant residual sugar. The resulting wine was light-bodied, off-dry and quite refreshing. As pointed out by Andrew Tierney this would compliment a tray of fruit and cheese nicely on a warm summer afternoon, or offset a nice stinky blue-veined cheese after dinner - 88/100.

Before I launch into the red wines we tasted I think a general note about the winemaking philosophy at Torbreck is warranted: most of the vineyards they source from are old vines: 40-140 years old! Even their "young" vines are at least 20 years old and they keep crop levels very low - 1-2 tons per acre and in some vineyards not even 1 ton/acre. They harvest later than most Barossa producers because they want ripe phenolics (tannins) in the skins and the seeds and they aren't worried about how much sugar ends up in the grapes. They destem the bunches and carry out fermentations under controlled temperature conditions, typically in the 25-28 °C range (77-83 °F), which is quite cool. This helps to preserve the freshness of the fruit and limits the amount of extraction that takes place during fermentation. The barrel regimen differs depending on the wine, but only French oak is used (now) and they do not fine or filter their red wines before bottling. The resulting wines show an amazing purity of fruit, elegant balance of fruit & acid and a refined tannin structure. While I didn't go gaga over all of the wines, as a group they were very enjoyable and we learned that they are very ageable too. Now on to the wines.

Flight 2

2008 Cuvée Juveniles

The name might imply that young vines are the source here, but in fact the youngest are 40 years old and the oldest are 140 years old. This wine sees nothing but stainless steel so there are no oak influences, just rich, ripe Barossa fruit comprised of 60% Grenache and 20% each Shiraz & Mataro (Mourvedre), a GSM blend. Medium ruby-red color with alluring aromas of blueberry and black raspberry with a hint of dried herbs mid-palate, this is an easy-to-drink wine with a very supple finish - 90/100.

2006 The Steading

This wine has the same pedigree as the Juveniles - about 45 different sources of fruit, vinified separately and blended after each barrel has been assessed for its virtues. The assemblage was aged in older French Hogshead barrels (300 liters or ~79 gallons) for 24 months before bottling. Lovely aromatics of pie cherry, black raspberry, and a hint of dried herbs here too. Very open-knit and easy to approach The Steading has a long finish that gets tightened up ever so slightly by fine-grained tannins - 90/100.

2001 The Steading

This vintage was aged in older American and French barrels. Not as open aromatically as the 2006 but still very fresh and exciting with all of the power exhibited by the younger wine. This is very much like a great southern Rhone blend with aromas of garrigue, black pepper and raspberry reduction, still going strong but should probably be drunk over the next 3 years - 91/100.

2006 Les Amis

100% Grenache from a vineyard planted in 1901 aged in 100% new French oak. Dense ruby-red in the glass with rich aromas of black raspberry, black cherry and Asian spices followed by a hint of oak near the finish this is a beautiful wine that is just starting to emerge. This layered beauty is hiding its best for later and will reward a few years aging - 93/100.

Flight 3

2009 Saignée

Saignée (sane-yeah) is a French term that means "to bleed the vats". It's the most common way to make rosé wine. After a brief period of contact between the skins and the juice some of the juice is "bled" off of the must and then fermented separately, in this case in well seasoned 300 liter Hogsheads. This results in a medium watermelon-pink rosé that is very much like a Bandol rosé from the Provence region of France. Sporting a spicy nose of wild strawberries, dried herbs and dried cherry this is a serious  
rosé that will pair well with seafood - 90/100.

2006 The Pict

100% Mataro (Mourvedre) from a single plot of ancient vines aged in 100% new French oak for 24 months, this is not a wine for the faint of heart! A glass-staining deep purple color with scents of black currants, blueberry, blackberry jam and a certain musky herbal note that speaks of forest floor and mushrooms. This is dense, concentrated and a bit rustic. The finish goes on and on. I love it! - 94/100

Flight 4

2008 Woodcutter's Shiraz

This is the workhorse wine for Torbreck and they make some 30,000 cases of it. 2008 was extremely hot and was a drought year as well resulting in some very ripe grapes. As mentioned above Torbreck is accustomed to handling ripe grapes but in this case the alcohol was a bit more evident on the finish. On the nose I get plum, Asian spices, and blueberry. The wine exhibits a nice mouthfeel and a lengthy finish - 87/100.

2006 The Struie

The 2006 The Struie is 100% Shiraz, sourced from cooler, hillside sites, 70% from Barossa Valley and 30% from Eden Valley with vine age ranging from 46 to 110 years. It was aged for 18 months in 20% new oak. At this point the tannins are more prominent in this wine probably because the cooler sites provide more restrained fruit but give this baby another 4 or 5 years of cellaring and it will be incredible. Opaque purple in the glass with scents of blueberry, blackberry, and a whiff of minerals the fruit is balanced by dusty tannins on the lingering finish - 90/100.

2001 The Struie

The 2001 Struie has a similar composition to the 2006 and is surprisingly still very primary in its aromatic expression but there is a bit of meaty, gamey Syrah in there. Dense ruby color with aromas of red and black fruits intermingled with scents of violet and black pepper - 88/100.

Flight 5

2006 The Factor

One of my favorite wines of the tasting this 100% Shiraz is assembled from lots harvested from the oldest, most revered vineyards in the Barossa. It spent 24 months in 30% new oak and boasts a dense purple/black color in the glass. Aromas of violets, licorice, smoke and pepper lead to an explosion in the mouth of blackberry, licorice and slowly unfolding red fruits mid-palate gliding into a very persistent finish. Still very youthful, very Barossa-ish but not at all overdone - 94/100.

2003 The Factor

This version is still inky purple in the glass and just now starting to show some of the secondary characteristics of Syrah that reveal themselves as a slightly sweet & sour element. I first detected blackberry and cherry notes followed by plum and a hint of espresso. After about 15 minutes in the glass I got some tar and spice aromas along with more blackberry and plum framed by fine-grained tannins - 93/100

2007 Descendent

This vineyard was planted by Dave Powell in 1994 with cuttings off old RunRig vineyards - some of the oldest genetic material in Australia. The Barossa's first co-fermented Shiraz/Viognier, Descendant has been joined by many more in the last couple of years - a testament to its success. Composed of 92% Shiraz and 8% Viognier sourced from a single vineyard this dense ruby-red beauty displays an explosively perfumed bouquet of violets, cherry, black olive and a hint of vanilla. The powerful aromas are echoed on the palate along with currant and black pepper. A very powerful, intense and concentrated but elegant expression of Barossa fruit - 94/100.

2001 Descendent

92% Shiraz and 8% Viognier sourced from a single vineyard as above that gets aged in 2.5 year old barrels previously used for RunRig. This elegantly styled effort exudes power without being heavy. Aromatically it opens with blackberry, cassis, licorice and Asian spices followed on the palate by silky tannins framing lush cassis, raspberry and a hint of coffee. Seemless and elegantly delicious - 95/100.

RunRig Flight

1997 RunRig

Still sporting a saturated black-ruby color in the glass this is the flagship offering from Torbreck. Made with select lots of fruit harvested from 80-140 year old vines and aged for 30 months in 100% new French oak. After thirteen years there is no oak present in the aromatic profile or on the palate. The 5% Viognier that is added right before bottling adds a pleasant aromatic lift but doesn't get in the way of the voluptuous, dense black fruits. Aromas of cassis, blackberry, licorice and bitter chocolate flow onto the palate where this superconcentrated wine persists for more than a minute after you swallow. This seems like it still has another decade of life left in it. Liquid silk - 95/100.

1999 RunRig

Dense ruby-purple color in the glass. Very powerful in a restrained style. Scents of plum, cedar and chocolate open up to reveal pepper and black raspberry. Cassis, blackberry and tar flavors are framed by fine-grained tannins that give way to a peppery, chocolatey finish. Very concentrated without being heavy. Ready to drink now - 95/100.

2001 RunRig

Inky ruby-purple color. Concentrated scents of blueberry, plum and baking spices are echoed on the palate along with black raspberry and chocolate. Immensely satisfying and lengthy finish where you barely detect any tannins but the wine is not at all fat, but rather harmonious and full-bodied - 94/100.

2002 RunRig

Also inky-purple in the glass. A little more of the viognier element is exhibited here as apricot and honeysuckle notes. Aromas of blackberries, licorice, violets and chocolate. On the palate the wine is amazingly complex with dense layers of blueberry, plum, licorice and coffee surrounded by silky tannins. Incredibly lengthy finish that lasts for over a minute - 94/100.

2005 RunRig

I didn't care for this wine as there was obvious volatile acidity. One of the members of the tasting group, Riggs Fulmer, commented that he liked the wine because it was a "little naughty" and he isn't put off by such things. I like a bit of Brett in some of my wines and I can get behind some funk too, but this just didn't appeal to me. It may have been this specific bottle because the wine received rave reviews from the press...

2006 RunRig

Glass (and tooth)-staining purple color. High notes from the Viognier show themselves early but are overtaken by black and blue fruits in the form of blueberry pie, black raspberry compote with a pretty, savory note thrown in for good measure on the persistent finish. While still very primary in its evolution this was my second favorite wine of the tasting. These RunRig wines exhibit incredible power but remain perfectly balanced and elegant - 96/100.

Thank you to Rob Moller and Andrew Tierney for a thoroughly enjoyable afternoon and a closing note. While many of these wines are expensive and out of reach for most consumers, they demonstrate that meticulous farming and fastidious winemaking can result in wines that exhibit power, grace and elegance even in the land of Yellowtail Shiraz!

Washington Wine Road Trip Part 3

On Wednesday we were on the road at 7:30 am headed for Yakima Valley where my group visited Airfield Estates. After a few punch downs and pump overs we observed a mobile bottling line put some of their finished product into final packaging. The use of these semi-trucks for bottling is very popular and a smart  business decision considering the cost of an in-place bottling system and the fact that it would sit dormant for 10-11 months of the year.


The empty bottles are slightly over-filled on a rotary table (in the background) then pass through a station that aspirates the excess guaranteeing that each bottle is filled properly. The next station puts the Stelvin closure on (screw cap) before the bottles head to the labeling section of the line. After labeling the finished product is returned via conveyor belt  to the same area where the empty bottles were taken out of their boxes. Empty bottles into the back of the semi and full, labeled bottles back out minutes later, pretty slick.

Because we did the winery exercise first on this day we ended up tasting wines pretty early in the day. But hey, we're professionals! After tasting through the lineup of Airfield Estates wines we were bussed over to the DuBrul Vineyard for our Yakima Valley Vineyard Exercise. If you haven't been to this part of the world you definitely need to head up to Yakima Valley. Most of the landscape is desert-looking and you would not think that anything worth eating could grow there. And if there wasn't adequate river water available for irrigation nothing would.

As the bus made its way up the hill I kept asking myself "would I ever think to plant a vineyard here - no!". We were greeted by Hugh, Kathy and Kerry Shiels, owners of DuBrul Vineyard (and Cote Bonneville). This property, originally planted in 1992, sits on a primarily south-facing slope looking out across the Yakima River toward the newest AVA in Washington, Snipes Mountain. The soil is littered with rocks and the aspect (tilt with respect to direction) changes every 30-40 meters making for a difficult-to-manage vineyard. But manage it they do and a number of prominent wineries seek out the grapes grown here including Owen Roe and Woodward Canyon. If you read the previous post you can see what they do with this precious crop under their own label "Cote Bonneville". Really well-made wines if a bit on the expensive side.

Our afternoon exercise was a tour of Red Willow Vineyard followed by a Syrah Comparative Tasting Workshop. The vineyard is a unique site situated in the North West corner of the Yakima Valley on the Yakima Nation Indian Reservation. Because of its higher elevation (1200-1300 ft) this site was above the flood plain of the Lake Missoula floods which means the soils are really nutrient poor and more ancient than most of the other vineyard sites in Yakima Valley. The list of varietals grown here is extensive and some of the oldest plantings of Syrah in the state of Washington are here too. A prominent feature in the vineyard is the small chapel that sits atop one of the highest points in the entire site. This was constructed by a local artisan from pictures of "Hermitage La Chapelle", a truly iconic vineyard on the east bank of the Northern Rhône that arguably grows some of the world's best Syrah. 

The Syrah tasting was exciting for me because I enjoy the varietal and more importantly because I see that Washington is capable of truly world-class Syrah. Once again we were given 3 known Washington Syrahs and 6 unknowns including 3 more from Washington. The known wines:

2006 Gramercy Cellars Lagniappe, Columbia Valley
Co-fermented with 3% Viognier; fermented with 40% whole clusters. "Lagniappe" is a Creole term to denote a little bonus that a friendly shopkeeper might add to a purchase. By extension, it may mean "an extra or unexpected gift or benefit." This Syrah certainly gives a little extra by means of its incredible aromatics. This really reminds me of Northern Rhône wines with violets, dark berries and a hint of dried herbs on the nose. The palate shows elegance but no restraint with regard to intensity. I really like the texture of Greg's wines.

2006 Amavi Cellars Syrah, Walla Walla
Dark ruby color. There's more new oak on the nose here followed by violets, underbrush and white pepper. Densely packed layers of red fruits emerge along with fine tannins mid-palate and the finish is medium length.

2007 Owen Roe "Ex Umbris", Columbia Valley
I'm a big fan of David O'Reilley's wines and this is always one of my favorites. This vintage is deep ruby in color and exhibits aromas of plum, violets, leather and pepper all nicely wrapped up in velvety tannins for a long finish.

The "unknown" wines:

2006 Radio-Coteau Syrah "Las Colinas", Sonoma Coast
This was riper and fuller in body but still maintained a good sense of balance. Pepper, ripe berries, a hint of dried herbs and roasted meat with a medium-long finish of fine-grained tannins. I did guess California...

2006 L'Ecole No 41 Syrah Columbia Valley
This was a much more restrained style with earthy, gamey notes that made me believe it was from France...

2005 Langmeil "Orphan Bank" Barossa Valley, Australia
This one too was a little rough around the edges and didn't strike me as New World in style. It definitely didn't have the typical power I associate with Barossa Valley Shiraz.

2007 Betz Family WInery "La Cote Rousse" Syrah, Red Mountain
Purple ink in the glass, the 2007 La Cote Rousse is 100% Syrah primarily from Kiona and Ciel du Cheval Vineyards. This smelled voluptuous and tasted even better! Based on the nose I thought this might be from the Northern Rhone but once in my mouth I guessed Washington. Very dense and layered on the palate with fine-grained, mouth-coating tannins and an exceptionally long finish. Really good stuff.

2005 Columbia Winery Syrah Red Willow Vineyard, Yakima Valley
Deep ruby/garnet color. My least favorite of the bunch because of its lack of precision. Rather chunky in style the wine seemed out of balance (perhaps it needed a bit more acid?).

2005 Domaine Durand Cornas,  Rhone Valley
Dark ruby-red color. Lovely aromatics of lavender, ripe red berries and a meaty component thrown in for good measure. This was classic Northern Rhone style Syrah with chewy structure and power without excess weight.

I must say that I have high hopes for Washington State Syrah. I think this varietal will eclipse Merlot and Cabernet over the next 10 years in terms of world recognition. After the Syrah comparative tasting we were bussed to Woodinville for a nice dinner hosted by Chateau Ste Michelle were I sat with Brennon Leighton of Efeste Wine Cellars and Chris Sparkman of Sparkman Cellars. What a couple of down-to-earth winemakers that like to have fun! They kept me in stitches all night long.

Washington Wine Road Trip Part 2

Day three began at a little more reasonable 7 am. I don't mind getting up early, that's what I do every day. But many of the group work in the restaurant world where 2-3 am calling it quits is the norm and getting up at 5:30 is not. After an hours drive my group ended up at Goose Ridge Vineyard, the largest contiguous vineyard in the state of Washington at 1400 acres.

Goose Ridge makes wine under their name as well as the Stonecap brand. They also sell fruit to a number of other wineries in the area. We drove out into the vineyard and met up with some of the Goose Ridge people along with the Chateau Ste Michelle director of vineyard operations, Kevin Corliss. He talked to us about how they manage the water program in the vineyard to facilitate canopy management. By denying the vines water at the right time they can halt vegetative growth and limit the amount of manual labor involved in leaf thinning. We also got to see first hand how a mechanical harvester works when they drove it right over our heads while we cowered against the adjacent row. The harvester straddles a row and "fingers" reach into the vines and strip the grapes off onto a conveyor that deposits them into a bin on another vehicle that travels in parallel down another row. They claim that the process is gentle but it looked to me like there was a lot of damage done to the grapes and a fair amount of leaf material included in the mix. Interestingly enough the Goose Ridge wines are hand-picked while the Stonecap wines are mechanically harvested.

We got a brief tour of the facility which is divided into two operations: a (relatively) small space devoted to the Goose Ridge wines where they use oak barrels for ageing the reds and a large space filled with giant (25,000 gallon) stainless steel tanks used for the Stonecap production where oak chips are used to impart that component. Charlie Hoppes, the winemaker, lead us through a tasting of their wines. He also has his own brand, Fidelitas. The Stonecap wines were uninteresting to me. They were not flawed but they had no soul. They are meant to hit the shelves at less than $10, but with all of the great value wines from Italy, France, Spain and South America that exhibit real character, I say pass on these. The Goose Ridge wines had more depth and nuance.

2006 Goose Ridge Cabernet Sauvignon
Medium-dark ruby color. A nice burst of red fruits when it first hits your palate is followed up by some sage and olive notes. The tannins are ripe and it has a medium-long finish.

2005 Goose Ridge Vireo
39% Syrah, 37% Merlot and 24% Cabernet Sauvignon. This has more dark fruit elements along with a hint of cocoa on the finish. The supple mouthfeel and smooth, ripe tannins make this very enjoyable.

We were bussed over to Anthony's at Columbia Point in Richland for a luncheon hosted by Jeff Gordon of Gordon Brothers Family Vineyards. Following lunch we broke up into different teams once again for our afternoon "vineyard exercises". My group was hosted by Tim and Kelly Hightower of Hightower Cellars located in the Red Mountain AVA. Our work focussed on determining if a block was ready to pick. We walked between two rows collecting berries randomly from both sides and placing them into ziplock bags. Once back in the winery we crushed the grapes while still inside the bags and tested the resulting juice for pH and sugar content. We also looked at the seeds, or pips as they are called, to determine color (green - not ripe, brown - ripe) and to see how much pulp adhered to them (lots of slimy pulp attached - not ripe, little or no pulp - ripe). Tasting the seeds gives you the final input needed to make a decision. The consensus was that the block could use a little more time and because the weather was cooperating they would hold off another few days before picking. 

We were lead through the Hightower wines by Tim and Kelly who share all of the responsibilities at the winery. They are really nice, genuine people that share a passion for making great wine. When asked asked what else we wanted to do and Aaron pipped up with "can we just sit on the patio and drink some more wine?". Sure, was the reply and the glasses were taken out onto their deck that overlooks the Yakima Valley. We watched the hawks circle lazily overhead and shared stories about wine and our lives for the next hour or so. All-in-all a very relaxing afternoon.

2006 Hightower Merlot
82% Merlot, 9% Cabernet Sauvignon, 9% Cabernet Franc (most of the fruit is sourced from Horse Heaven Hills with roughly 1/3 coming from Red Mountain). Medium-dark garnet color with black cherry, blackberry and a hint of roasted herb on the back end. Medium body with good overall balance and fine-grained tannins. Medium length finish.

2006 Hightower Cabernet Sauvignon
88% Cabernet Sauvignon, 7% Cabernet Franc, 5% Merlot (mostly Red Mountain fruit). Deep ruby color with black cherry, anise and currant aromas that are echoed on the palate. Mouth-coating (ripe) tannins provide a lovely texture to the wine and the finish lingers pleasantly for almost a minute.

2006 Hightower Red Mountain Red Wine
78% Cabernet Sauvignon, 22% Merlot (all Red Mountain fruit). This was my favorite of the bunch. Deep garnet color with aromas of cherry, wood smoke, cassis and sage followed by flavors of dark fruits and dried herbs. The texture is fantastic and the finish goes on and on. Really well made.

The regional tasting this day was held at the Precept Brands' Canyon Ranch facility. The tables were setup outside and not everyone was prepared for the cold air. During the tasting a bright, near-full moon rose over the Rattlesnake Hills to bathe the area in soft light. Following the tasting we enjoyed a nice dinner outside under propane heat lamps. Some of my favorites from this day:

2007 RiverAerie Malbec
Deep garnet in color with some earthy notes under the black cherry and plum. Good depth of fruit and a mouth-filling texture make you go back for another sip after enjoying the lengthy finish.

2005 Col Solare
71% Cabernet Sauvignon, 25% Merlot, 4% Cabernet Franc. Medium ruby color with ripe blackberry, plum and black cherry aromas that get delivered on the palate too. Very lengthy finish on this complex wine.

2006 Col Solare
72% Cabernet Sauvignon, 19% Merlot, 4% Cabernet Franc, 3% Petit Verdot, 2% Syrah. I don't know, a lot of people were really excited by this wine while I didn't care for it that much, at least not at this time, but then I'm not an oak slut either ;> Perhaps with some additional bottle ageing it will come together.

2007 Cote Bonneville Chardonnay DuBrul Vineyard
Medium golden yellow in the glass. Tangerine, pear and some tropical notes emerge from this well-balanced Chardonnay and the vibrant acidity really keeps the fruit core focussed.

2005 Cote Bonneville Carriage House Bordeaux Blend
Cabernet Sauvignon (73%), Merlot (26%) and Cabernet Franc (1%). Medium-dark garnet in color with lush aromas of dark cherries, plum and sweet spices. The flavors echo the aromatic profile and are wrapped up by velvety tannins that provide great texture to the wine.

2004 Cote Bonneville Estate DuBrul Vineyard Bordeaux Blend
63% Cabernet Sauvignon, 37% Merlot. Bright ruby-red. Aromas of redcurrant, licorice, and toasty oak. Sweet, lush and highly concentrated, with a candied quality to the flavors of currant, black cherry, and spices. A really elegant wine of great depth and complexity but at $120 it's a little too spendy.

2006 J. Bookwalter Protagonist Bordeaux Blend
A Merlot-based wine with aromas of menthol, cherry, blackberry and wood smoke. On the palate the shows focus and concentration with silky tannins and a long finish. First rate stuff.

2006 J. Bookwalter Foreshadow Cabernet Sauvignon
Another well made wine this one with a medium-dark ruby color in the glass and a complex array of aromas from black cherry and currant to dried herbs and cocoa. Layers of fruit unfold on the palate and the fine-grained tannins hold it all together for a long, long finish that begs for another sip.

2006 Owen Roe DuBrul Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon
Medium-dark garnet color. Blackberry, currant and dried herb aromas follow through onto the palate where vibrant acidity holds the ripe fruit in check into the lingering finish.


Top 100 & Wine Scores in General

Wine Scores and the Top 100

Wine scores are both loved and reviled by members of the wine trade. On the one hand, when you put a wine on the shelf that has a score of 95 points it practically sells itself while on the other hand a wine that got 87 points can languish on the shelf for a long time even if it represents a great value. It is my observation that 88 points is about the bottom of the threshold to pique peoples' interest even though the Wine Spectator scale lumps values of 85-89 as "Very good: a wine with special qualities" and Robert Parker who championed the 100 point scale back in 1978 lumps 80-89 point wines as "A barely above average to very good wine displaying various degrees of finesse and flavor as well as character with no noticeable flaws".

As a former scientist by training it is interesting to read the Wine Spectator tasting methodology: Wine Spectator or that from Robert Parker's Wine Advocate: Wine Advocate. You get the sense that there is actually some degree of precision to be accorded their scores vis-à-vis the rigor they employ. I almost wonder that they don't employ fractional points. Blah, blah, blah! Wine tasting is one of the most subjective activities you can hope to find and our palates and the wines we taste are a moving target. If you taste the same wine once a month over the course of a year you would find that your impression would be different on some occasions. This can be the result of changes in your health, what you ate for your last meal, your mental state when you taste and a myriad other factors that affect your sense of smell (after all 'tasting' is in reality mostly 'smelling').

Does this mean that professional taster's scores are meritless? No, I like and use scores in my shop, (when they are good scores ;> of course), because they help sell wine. But buyers need to understand that scores represent (most of the time) a single point in time, from a single individual based on a single bottle of wine. As I said, your sense of taste is affected by many things and is constantly changing along with the wine that is evolving in the bottle. Wines are living things and change profoundly over time. I am surprised sometimes when I taste a wine and decide to bring it into the store only to find that there is a bad review (or perhaps not bad but unflattering). Often the review was written immediately following release of the wine and it has undergone a positive transformation in the interim. Good scores can be used as the basis to begin exploring a wine to see if you like it but a high score is no guarantee that you will like it. My customers are often surprised when I tell them that I could line up ten100 point wines and if they tasted them blind they may not like more than half of them. Scores only provide one clue about the wine. The language used to describe it provides much greater insight into the nature of the wine and whether or not you might enjoy it. Reading "93 points - Hedonistic, jammy, coat-your-mouth style" does not bode well if you prefer wines with finesse and elegance. 

I actually like the system that Dorothy J. Gaiter and John Brecher use for their Wall Street Journal wine column "Tastings". They employ a simple 6 level rating with the following possibilities: Yech, OK, Good, Very Good, Delicious, and Delicious! Once again, there is no precision to tasting wine so don't imply precision where none can be found. I like the simplicity of their system and it offers their readers more latitude to agree with their assessments. I also like their "winespeak" which utilizes simple language that conveys more about how the wine made them feel rather than a technical description of the flavor profile and tannin structure.

Ok, that damned Top 100! I hate that list, primarily because most of the wines are gone from the market by the time it gets published and there are always a bunch of disappointed customers that want to get their hands on some of the top 10 wines. I have been fortunate for the past three years that I have tasted many of the Top 100 wines before they gained their esteemed positions and was prescient enough to bring some 30-35 of them into the store during the course of the year so that I could hold my annual Top 100 Tasting for a few dozen people. Of course in many cases the only bottles I have left are those for the tasting so again I have unhappy customers that want to purchase their favorites that don't exist anymore. Oh well, it serves as a good reason to get together and pull the corks on a bunch of good wines, viva la Top 100!

My best advice is to get out there and taste wine. There is no substitute for actually putting the wine in your mouth to determine if you like it or not. And I always tell my customers: "Drink what you like, just buy it from me!"

Washington Wine Road Trip Part 1

DAY 1 - Seattle

First of all, kudos to the Washington Wine Commission. In the middle of the harvest season they managed to put together an incredible journey through Washington's most significant wine regions giving the 40 of us an opportunity to interact with the most influential growers and winemakers in the state. And my personal thanks to the many growers and winemakers that took the time to enlighten us about what makes Washington wines so special during their most critical moments of the 2009 vintage.

I must admit that my impression of Washington wines before this trip was that most of them were over-extracted, highly-alcoholic and showed no precision. A tasting I attended a few years ago that featured Washington wines left me wondering if the winemakers had ever been to Bordeaux or the Rhone Valley. But I must confess that I now have a new-found appreciation for the wines from most of the major regions of Washington, and I look forward to the next releases that hold even more promise.

Our adventure began in Seattle, at the Edgewater Hotel where Shayn Bjornholm, MS provided an overview of the Washington state wine scene (MS is Master Sommelier, a.k.a. Wine Geek!). If you haven’t heard the story of the Missoula Floods, ask me. I am not going to take up space here writing about it,but it is fascinating and key to understanding the geology of the current Pacific Northwest and why there are so many world-class wines made here. We then proceeded over to the Space Needle for a reception that included tasting wines from the Puget Sound region, Lake Chelan as well as some of the wineries that are located in the area who source grapes from other areas of Washington.

Notable wines (in alphabetical order, not necessarily by preference):

2006 Andrew Will Two Blondes Vineyard Red Blend, Yakima Valley

43%Cabernet Franc, 29% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 28% Merlot. Dense and concentrated.  It offers up aromas of cinnamon, sage, incense, black cherry, and black currant. This is a supple, ripe wine with fine-grained tannins, savory flavors, and excellent  balance. 

2006 Andrew Will Ciel du Cheval Red Blend, Red Mountain

40%Merlot, 37% Cabernet Franc, 19% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 4% Petit Verdot. Dense purple in color, it has an outstanding bouquet of cedar, baking spices, blackcurrant, and blackberry. This has a very lengthy finish. 

2006 Cadence Bel Canto Bordeaux Blend, Red Mountain

52%Cabernet Franc and 48% Merlot, so this is a take on the right bank region of Saint-Emilion. A lively wine with aromas and flavors of black currant and black cherry and silky tannins that coat your mouth. 

2007 Cadence Coda Bordeaux Blend, Red Mountain

57%Merlot, 18% Cabernet Sauvignon, 13% Cabernet Franc, and 12% Petit Verdot. The “value” wine from Cadence that offers aromas of black currant, toasted oak and a floral note that extend onto the palate. This has less structure than the Bel Canto but offers more immediate enjoyment. 

2006 Soos Creek Wine Cellars Ciel du Cheval Vineyard Bordeaux Blend, Red Mountain

67%Cabernet Sauvignon, 17% Cabernet Franc and 16% Merlot. Bright red-ruby. Dense,smoky nose of berries and cassis with floral scents, with a distinct viscosity to the very ripe dried fruit and nutty oak flavors with undertones of chocolate, mocha, licorice, minerals, ripe tannins and dusty earth. 

2007 Syncline Cuvée Elena, Columbia Valley

70%Grenache, 17% Mourvedre, with Carignan, Cinsault and Syrah making up the balance. Very reminiscent of Chateauneuf-du-Pape with concentrated aromas of bright red fruits along with herbs-de-provence. On the palate this is silky and intense. The finish lasted several minutes!

Following the regional tasting we had about the only freetime that we would see for the next 5 days (unless you count 11:30 pm – 5:30 am free time…). I tried to get over to Pike Place Market but they roll up the sidewalks early on Sundays so I ended up at a great sushi bar, Umi Sake House (2230 First Ave, Seattle). By far the best sushi I’ve had since relocating up here 5 years ago. Extensive sake list, freshest fish around and the head chef is very creative. Give it a try if you’re in the area. By the way, it was absolutely beautiful in Seattle that day.

Day 2 – Walla Walla

After a 5:30 am wake-up call we headed to SeaTac airport for a short flight down to Pasco where we boarded busses that took us to Walla Walla. We broke up into groups of 6-8 for the vineyard exercises and my group visited with Tom Waliser of Beresan Winery. While the Walisers only own 18 acres of vineyards, Tom and his crew are responsible for farming something like 30-40% of the total acreage in Walla Walla including Pepper Bridge Vineyard. Tom talked to us about how they mitigate winter hazards like freezing with smudge pots and large fans to move the cold air out of the vineyard. He also mentioned that most of the vineyards are planted in a north-south orientation and that the canopy is not trimmed symmetrically. They pull more canopy from the east side so that the grapes there get more exposure to the early morning sun and they leave more canopy on the west side to help protect the bunches there from the blazing hot afternoon sun.

We rejoined our companions for a comparative tasting of Rieslings from around the world. We were given 9 wines and had information about the first 3 that were from Washington. We then blind tasted the other 6 and had to try and determine where they came from knowing that there were 3 more Washington Rieslings among them. They were easy to pick out. With few exceptions I am not a fan of  Washington Riesling. They just don’t have the same precision that I find in good German, Austrian and even Australian Riesling. I got the Mosel and Australian versions but I thought that the other one was from Austria, but it was Alsatian.

After lunch we broke up into different groups and headed out to a bunch of the local wineries. I got to spend time with Greg Harrington at Gramercy Cellars. Greg was the youngest American to pass the Master Sommelier exam at the age of 26 and then spent time as a sommelier and wine program director for Wolfgang Puck, Emeril Legasse and Joyce Goldstein before turning to his true passion, making wine. He has a fairly minimalistic approach and doesn’t like to mess around too much with the wines. He uses more stems in his syrahs than many of the winemakers I talked to and the rich texture and mouthfeel that he achieves is at least in part due to this. 

We were supposed to “experience” punch downs, but we had all “been there, done that” so we opted to taste some of the current ferments tha twere percolating in open-top fermentors. It was interesting to taste such primary wine that still had a little residual sugar. It was hard for me to tell where the wines would end up after completing fermentation.

After a quick shower at the Marcus Whitman we were taken to a Walla Walla regional tasting at L’Ecole No. 41 where 22 wineries poured their best wines for us including: Abeja, Beresan Estate Vineyard, Bergevin Lane, Buty, Cougar Crest, Dunham Cellars, Gramercy Cellars, L’Ecole No. 41, Long Shadows Vintners, Nicholas Cole Cellars, Northstar, Pepper Bridge Winery, Reininger Winery, Seven Hills Winery, Sleight of Hand Cellars, Spring Valley Vineyards, Tamarack Cellars, Walla Walla Vintners, Waterbrook Winery, Waters/Wines of Substance and Woodward Canyon. Too many good wines to write up but I will include some of my favorites. 

2007 Abeja Chardonnay

This Chardonnay has a lovely texture wrapped around tropical flavors of pineapple and star fruit along with spiced pear. Beautifully balanced where the oak is an ingredient, not the dominant character. Long finish. 

2006 Abeja Cabernet Sauvignon

Deep red-ruby. Another wonderfully textured example with a core of raspberry, redcurrant, tobacco and licorice. Broad and sweet, with pliant, harmonious flavors of plum, raspberry, currant, leather and mocha. The long finish has ripe mouth-coating tannins that are very smooth. 

2006 Bergevin Lane Cabernet Sauvignon

76% Cabernet Sauvignon, 16% Merlot,5% Cabernet Franc, and 3% Petit Verdot aged for 20 months in 60% new French, American, and Eastern European oak. This one is wine ink – very deep purple color with a bouquet of graphite, black cherry, blackberry, and violets. Darkfruits, licorice and chocolate on the palate with supple tannins make for a complete package. 

2006 Cougar Crest Cabernet Franc

To be honest I prefer Loire Valley Cab Franc. But for those of you out there that like big, beefy styled CF this is the one for you. Bold red currant and red berry flavors on a polished frame of supple tannins. Very long finish. 

2006 Dunham Cellars Trutina

49% Cabernet Sauvignon, 48% Merlot,and 3% Syrah. No lack of oak in this one but it is well integrated with the lush black cherry, blackberry and licorice flavors. Great depth of fruit and fine-grained tannins that linger on and on. Good Value. 

2005 Dunham Cellars Syrah

Dense purple color with aromas of smoked meats, violets, and fresh cracked black pepper. A very supple texture with ripe blackberry, currant and boysenberry flavors on a sleek frame of fine tannins. 

2006 Gramercy Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon

Medium-dark ruby red color. Lovely bouquet of black cherry, blackberry, and sweet pipe tobacco. Excellent balance of fruit, acid and oak with mouth-coating fine-grained tannins that firm up the long finish. 

2007 Gramercy Cellars Syrah Walla Walla

This reminds me of Syrah from the Rhône Valley. Purple hued with aromas of bacon, black olives, underbrush and dark berries. On the palate there are rich layers of dark berries, black pepper and tapenade framed by smooth tannins. 

2007 Gramercy Cellars Syrah John Lewis

He used 100% stems in this version and the texture was incredible. Dense, concentrated dark fruit flavors accented by smoked meats and sage are wrapped up by the mouth-coating tannins that provide an incredibly long finish. 

2007 Gramercy Cellars “Inigo Montoya” Tempranillo, Walla Walla

"Hello. My name is Inigo Montoya. You killed my father. Prepare to die.” In Rioja new American oak is commonly used for their Tempranillo. Here winemaker Greg Harrington used 1 year old barrels to let the fruit shine through and the result is stunning. Earthy, spicy aromas waft out of the glass and the palate reveals layers of dark fruits, smoke and a lengthy finish. 

2006 L’Ecole No. 41 Apogee, Pepper Bridge Vineyard

46% Cabernet Sauvignon, 42% Merlot, 8% Malbec, and 4% Cabernet Franc. Dense crimson color with aromas of black currant, graphite, and blackberry that are echoed on the palate along with some plum and black cherry notes. Very supple texture and a long finish. 

2006 Sequel Syrah (Long Shadows Vintners)

I’ve been a fan of this wine since its first vintage and this might be the best yet. 96% Syrah and 4% Cabernet Sauvignon aged for 18 months in 65% new French oak. Aromas of bacon, black pepper, blackberry and violets give way to a palate of concentrated layers of dark fruits, spice, smoke and fine-grained tannins with a long, long finish. 

2006 Pedestal Merlot (Long Shadows Vintners)

Move over Sideways! This is a Merlot that everyone will love because of the rich layers of fruit and supple texture. 86% Merlot, 8% Cabernet Sauvignon, 4% Petit Verdot and 2% Malbec aged for 22 months in 85% new French oak. OK, so it’s not all Merlot! Dark fruits dominate the bouquet along with some graphite and spice box notes and on the palate this really delivers the goods with an exceptionally long, smooth finish. 

2006 Spring Valley Uriah

54% Merlot, 33% Cabernet Franc, and the balance Petit Verdot and Malbec. It spent 18 months in French oak. Currants, blackberries and espresso all wrapped up in smooth tannins and the finish goes on and on. 

2006 Waterbrook Melange

28% Cabernet Franc, 21% Syrah, 19% Cabernet Sauvignon, 17% Sangiovese, 14% Merlot, 1% Tempranillo. Aromas of cedar, spice and dark stone fruit marry with delicious flavors of dark chocolate and toasted oak. Balanced tannins and lingering fruit round out the finish. Good value. 

2006 Waterbrook Reserve Merlot

99% Merlot, 1% Cabernet Sauvignon aged in 39% new oak. It is dark ruby-colored with aromas of, cassis, and black cherry. Moderately structured on the palate, this medium-bodied effort has plenty of ripe, spicy fruit, good balance, and a medium long, fruit-filled finish.  

2006 Woodward Canyon Cabernet Sauvignon Artist Series

87% Cabernet Sauvignon and 13%Syrah (the first time Syrah has been used as a component in this wine). A deep purple color, with scents of violets, spice box, black currant, and a hint of blueberry. Densely packed flavors of black cherry and currant along with ripe mouth-coating tannins. 

After tasting through a lot of wines we walked next door to Woodward Canyon and were treated to a very nice dinner in their new “Reserve House”. This newly created space is for private, sit-down tastings of their current and limited reserve wines. It’s a gorgeous facility and we had a great time mingling with the winemakers while we continued to enjoy their wines with food. 

The buses whisked us back to the Marcus Whitman in Walla Walla and at about 10:30pm there was “Beer Hall”: coolers packed with ice cold micro brews were brought into the foyer of the hotel and we had a chance to get to know one another a little better. You can’t imagine how good a cold beer can taste after slurping and spitting wine all day!

Reed's Ginger Brews

Reed’s Ginger Brews

I should preface this review with the statement that I am not a soda drinker. Water and wine make up 99% of my beverage menu, although there was a time when I did drink Canada Dry Ginger Ale on a regular basis. So when my long-time friend Jim Linesch asked me to evaluate the Reed products like I would a typical wine I thought “what the heck, I do have a reference for my evaluation, so here we go!”

The packaging is very nice, 4-packs of clear lime-green bottles with a tropical island look to the label, presumably representing the Jamaican heritage of the Original Ginger Brew. I like the twist-off caps that are color-coded to distinguish the three different ginger brews.

Looking at the back label for the ingredients list provides some insight into the intent at Reed’s:  “Freshly brewed from: sparkling filtered water (sweetened by a blend of fructose, pineapple juice from concentrate and honey, fresh ginger root, lemon and lime juices from concentrate and spices. No preservatives or artificial anything!” At 37.4 g of sugar per 12 oz. bottle it comes in a little lower than your average soda (Coke is 39 g), but that’s still a lot of sugar. All of the Ginger Brews are 25% fruit juice.

First up: Reed’s Original Ginger Brew – The first sip was sweet to be sure, but not overly so and the distinctive flavor of ginger kicked right in. Now I like ginger and I cook with fresh ginger on a regular basis so this had a familiar spiciness to it and after my palate adjusted to the sweetness I liked this drink. The yin & yang of the sweetness vs. the ginger bite reminds me of a good German Riesling where residual sugar plays against bright natural acidity to provide harmony and balance.

I thought I observed some sediment kicked up from the bottom of the bottle when I first opened it so I poured some into a glass and sure enough there is some particulate material. This is a good thing in my opinion and reflects the desire to have a naturally brewed product in the bottle, not some pristine filter-out-all-the-good-stuff beverage, much akin to unfiltered wines. If I were rating this on a 100 point scale I would give it 88 Pts.

Next up: Reed’s Premium Ginger Brew – This is basically the same as the Original but is sweetened with Canadian white water clover honey, raw cane sugar and pineapple juice from concentrate (no fructose). The sweetness here is mellower and seems less pronounced and the honey component is easily identified here. Rating: 89 Pts.

Reed’s Extra Ginger Brew – This brew has 25 grams of fresh ginger compared to 17 grams for the Original & Premium labels and this is evident on the first sip. I like spicy foods and this is definitely more my style. The ginger bite is more prominent and for my palate brings more balance to the overall impression. Rating: 91 Pts.

Overall I liked these drinks and they would be a good foil for spicy barbeque, Thai and other similar fare where a little sweetness helps to balance the fire from capsaicin (chiles). As I said at the beginning I am not a soda drinker and for me these are too sweet for everyday drinking but the ginger element really is a nice departure from purely sweet soda pop.  If you see these, give them a try. I mentioned that I previously drank Canada Dry Ginger Ale and I wanted a fresh perspective on that beverage so I bought one and there is no comparison to the Reed’s products. Even though there is slightly less sugar (33 g vs 37.4 g) it tasted very sweet and had no balance to the sweet component like in the Reed’s Extra Ginger.

2007 Oregon Pinot Noir

The 2007 vintage of Willamette Valley Pinot Noirs is a minefield - some good, some very good, not many great, and lots of mediocre wines. << MORE >>

E. Guigal Tasting

I wish I had had more time to allow this to really open up. Needless to say I didn’t spit!<< MORE >>

2009 Taste Walla Walla & 2009 Gamberro Rosso Tre Bicchieri Tasting Notes

The Spring season of wine tasting events has begun and I had the good fortune of attending two really great ones this week. Monday was Taste Walla Walla<< MORE >>

Wine Tasting Etiquette

OK, time for a short rant about some of the things I see when we're out tasting wine or when I'm pouring wine at Wine Xing. Most of this is common sense and none of it is life-threatening, but I swear I want to threaten the lives of some people!

First and foremost: wine tasting is a sensory activity that involves all of the senses but most of the action takes place within the olfactory system (your sense of smell). Yes that's right 70% of tasting is smelling. You smell the wine directly by sniffing from the glass and when you swallow the wine the flavors that you detect are sensed by the same receptors via your retronasal passage (the part of your sinuses that connect your nose and throat). You really only taste 5 things directly in your mouth: sweet (sugar), sour (acid), bitter (tannin and to some extent alcohol), salty (not usually associated with wine) and umami (savory, like mushrooms). All of the other interesting flavors are detected by your sense of smell.

The bottom line: don't wear perfume, oils, or cologne. I know you want to smell nice on your wine excursion but strong perfume affects other people who are tasting and nobody will be able to detect that slight whiff of cinnamon in the Pinot Noir that the tasting notes mention when all they can smell is your cologne.

Sometimes the tasting area can get crowded. The biggest problem is when people make their way to the bar and hold the bar hostage. Be polite. Get your taste of wine, ask a pertinent question or two and then move away from the bar to let others gain access. This happens more at the trade tastings that we attend and I have to be rude sometimes just to get to the spit bucket. If you really must ask 50 questions about each wine, schedule a private tasting and go for it, but when there are lots of other people trying to taste the wine move away from the bar while you assess the wine and move back in when you want another sample.

Use the spit bucket. If you are driving you want to make sure that you keep your intake to a minimum. Taste and spit. If you're not comfortable spitting directly into the bucket ask for another glass that you can use to transfer your taste to the bucket (just remember which one is which!). Dump the unused portion of your taste into the bucket, nobody will be offended. If you don't like a wine, you don't need to announce to the whole room your displeasure, just dump it out. Rinse your glass with fresh water when you move from whites to reds or from reds to sweet wines, but don't rinse between every taste. The water will have a greater impact on the next wine more than the previous wine will in most instances.

Use your Inside Voice at all times. We're all guilty of it, me most assuredly. We get a little alcohol in us and the volume goes through the roof. I see this at Wine Xing every week. People come in get a taste or two, pretty soon there are 3 or 4 conversations going in the room and if this was a venue without alcohol I would still be able to talk to someone in front of me without raising my voice. Mix in a little vino though and I need to shout at people standing 3 feet away!

The food at the tasting table isn't your lunch, it's to help you clear your palate or give you an idea of how a wine goes with food. Don't abuse it.

Don't roll into the tasting room five minutes before they close-- that's not enough time to taste anything.